Many Arizona homeowners wonder if they should fix up their old pool or build a new one. Pool renovation costs can start as low as a few thousand dollars, while building new pools often costs much more. This guide explains the key differences and helps you see which choice might fit your needs and budget best.
Factors Influencing Pool Renovation Costs
Pool renovation costs can vary a lot. The size of the project and the materials chosen play big roles in this.
Assessing Renovation Scope and Materials
Start by evaluating your pool for any cracks, leaks, or broken tiles, as these issues can quickly increase renovation costs. In Arizona, common resurfacing options include plaster, pebble, quartz, and ecoFINISH.
- Plaster is the most affordable but typically lasts around 7 years.
- Pebble and quartz finishes can last over a decade, offering greater durability at a higher upfront cost.
- ecoFINISH provides a long-lasting, non-porous surface that resists fading, chipping, and algae growth.
- Liner replacement usually runs between $4,000 and $6,000 on average.
Cosmetic upgrades, such as new lighting or decorative tile, add extra expenses, while functional upgrades like pumps, filters, or energy-efficient systems can raise costs further—especially if you choose high-end models.
Smaller projects may only require patchwork or a fresh coat of paint, while a full remodel can be more expensive but delivers long-lasting results, improved performance, and easier maintenance.
Costs of Building a New Pool
New pool construction in Arizona can cost much more than a simple pool renovation. On average, building from scratch ranges between $40,000 and $80,000 for standard backyard pools.
Custom or luxury options push costs past $100,000 fast. Materials matter; concrete (gunite) costs the most but lasts longer. Fiberglass pools are cheaper but have fewer shape choices.
Yard size shapes your total bill too—smaller yards need extra planning and grading work. Permits in cities like Phoenix add up to thousands of dollars in fees before the first shovel hits dirt.
Then consider plumbing, lighting, decking, fences, and you realize that each upgrade brings new expenses to the table. Expect higher homeowner expenses for maintenance and cleaning the pools as well.
Construction time stretches out over months compared to quick remodel projects—weather delays can slow things down even more during Arizona’s monsoon season.
Comparing Renovations vs. New Construction
Renovating an old pool and building from scratch come with clear differences, especially in Arizona’s unique climate and housing market. Here’s a straight-up side-by-side breakdown.
| Aspect | Renovation | New Construction |
| Average Cost (2024) | $8,000 – $35,000 | $45,000 – $75,000+ |
| Time to Complete | 2–6 weeks | 2–5 months |
| Permitting | Usually fewer permits, sometimes none | More permits, stricter inspections |
| Demolition/Invasive Work | Minimal, often keeps existing shell | All new excavation, heavy equipment |
| Customization | Limited by current structure | Fully customizable design, size, and features |
| Long-term Value | Raises property value some, cost-effective | Big boost to home value, higher upfront spend |
| Energy Efficiency | Upgrade plumbing, lights, surface; new tech possible | Latest energy systems and automation, all options open |
| Disruption | Less mess, quicker recovery for yard | Significant impact on landscaping, daily life |
Conclusion
Deciding between renovating your existing pool or building a new one in Arizona is a big choice, but both options offer unique benefits. Renovations can breathe new life into an old pool, improving appearance, functionality, and efficiency, while a new construction gives you complete freedom to customize design, features, and materials.
No matter which path you choose, trust Copperstate Hot Shot Pool Finishes to handle your project from start to finish. Whether it’s a full pool renovation or a brand-new build, Copperstate ensures expert installation, durable materials, and a beautiful, long-lasting pool you’ll enjoy for years to come.